Amazon's Kuiper and SpaceX are clashing over SpaceX's request that the FCC Space Bureau impose an object-years condition on the Kuiper system. In an application for review, SpaceX said the bureau's granting a license modification for Kuiper in April "unreasonably deviated" from commission policy because it failed to impose the object-years condition, though it has been applied to multiple other non-geostationary orbit systems. In its opposition last month to the review application, Kuiper called the AFR "meritless." Kuiper said a 100 object-years condition -- that being a cap on the total cumulative time to deorbit failed Kuiper satellites -- isn't appropriate due to orbital characteristics, and the proposed Kuiper system is very different from SpaceX's proposed, much-larger, second-generation constellation, which had a 100 object-years condition on it. Kuiper's arguments against the AFR are "an Orwellian spin on the facts," SpaceX told the bureau this week. The bureau has applied the object-years condition numerous times, it said. The FCC can't wait for a rulemaking to address the reliability risk Kuiper presents, it said.
The FCC should deny Sateliot's petition for providing mobile satellite service in the 2 GHz band as it rejected a similar request from SpaceX, EchoStar told the agency's Space Bureau this week. EchoStar said Sateliot's proposed uplinks and downlinks in the band would interfere with its 5G broadband network. In addition, it said Sateliot's application makes "no practical sense," as Sateliot supposedly wants to use the 2 GHz band for narrowband IoT service for mobile network operators, but EchoStar, the only mobile network operator in the band, "does not want this service." In its April petition, Sateliot said its planned 10 smallsats and blanket-licensed terminals would minimally affect the band's other users. Sateliot said that while EchoStar's Dish Network is the sole licensee of the terrestrial AWS-4 service in the band, creation of that service and Dish's license were "never intended to transform the 2 GHz MSS band into primarily terrestrial spectrum."
NAB filed a petition for partial reconsideration of the FCC’s equal employment opportunity data collection order and Catholic broadcasters refiled and expanded their existing petition (see 2405010070), according to filings in docket 98-204 this week. The EEO order also was challenged in court (see 2405060057). NAB’s petition calls for the agency to reconsider making the broadcaster workforce diversity data publicly available and station specific and to reconsider changes to Form 395-B to allow for reporting of nonbinary genders. Making the data public violates the First and Fifth amendments and could threaten employee privacy, NAB said. “Given the Commission’s new categorization concerning non-binary employees, a number of broadcasters also have expressed concern on behalf of their employees who would be identified as such that they could be harassed,” NAB said. The FCC’s position that Congress requires it to regulate broadcaster EEO is wrong, and disclosing the data “will deliberately unleash pressure on stations to engage in preferential hiring practices,” NAB said. “The FCC effectively invites third-party activist groups to use the data for such inappropriate purposes.” The joint filing from Catholic broadcasters and groups including the Catholic Radio Association and the Sanctus Josephus Society has added another broadcaster to the 19 previously included in the petition. Jackson Lansing Catholic Radio has joined Archangel Communications, Holy Family Communications and others in calling on the FCC to reconsider the recognition of nonbinary gender in Form 395-B. The new filing also expands the Catholic broadcasters' First Amendment arguments. Speaking on a podcast Wednesday, an attorney representing one of the organizations pursuing a legal challenge to the EEO order condemned it as an attempt to control broadcasters and collect employee personal information. “They want to use this regulation to force organizations to use hiring practices for people of the LGBTQ persuasion that they prefer,” said Abraham Hamilton, general counsel of the American Family Association. Hamilton compared the public listing of the EEO data to the Southern Poverty Law Center’s listing of hate groups and said the FCC wants to force broadcasters to “capitulate” to “the Biden administration’s obsession with the LGBTQIAP+ sexual deviancy sociopolitical agenda.”
Summit Ridge Group “achieved more than $500 million in approved reimbursements for its clients” through multiple FCC programs, it said. That includes through the TV broadcast repack, C-band clearance and Secure and Trusted Communications Program, a Wednesday news release said. Summit Ridge’s “success in reaching the $500 million reimbursement mark reflects its expertise and dedication to understanding and efficiently navigating the intricate landscape of FCC compliance regulations,” the company added.
Milwaukee and Lima, Ohio, opposed giving FirstNet and AT&T control of the 4.9 GHz band in the latest filings on the hotly contested spectrum (see 2406040018). The Public Safety Spectrum Alliance's proposal “would strip today’s 4.9 GHz public safety licensees’ right to expand their systems by forcing incumbent licensees to surrender spectrum they are not using,” Milwaukee Mayor Cavalier Johnson (D) said: “It would move the band to AT&T’s FirstNet network, which runs counter to a 2023 FCC order and its commitment to locally controlled public safety in the 4.9 GHz band.” Lima Mayor Sharetta Smith (D) warned the city “may lose rights to access the band and the vital resiliency it provides for emergency communications.”
The Senate Commerce Committee said Wednesday night it will mark up the Spectrum and National Security Act (S-4207) June 12, as expected (see 2406050056). S-4207 would restore the FCC’s spectrum auction authority through Sept. 30, 2029, lend the commission more than $10 billion in FY 2024 funding for the expired affordable connectivity program and fully fund the Secure and Trusted Communications Networks Reimbursement Program. The Wednesday meeting would be Senate Commerce’s third attempt at marking up S-4207 after pulling it from consideration on two previous occasions (see 2405160066). The meeting will begin at 10 a.m. in 253 Russell. Republican FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr appeared to oppose S-4207 during a Thursday news conference. It’s “not clear to me that” S-4207 “gets the job done,” Carr told reporters. It “largely aligns with the Biden administration’s approach on spectrum” highlighted in its national spectrum strategy. Carr has repeatedly criticized the Biden spectrum strategy since its November release (see 2311130048). “I don’t think it is going to get us back to moving on spectrum with the same pace and cadence that we had” under former FCC Chairman Ajit Pai, Carr said: “We need to start clearing more spectrum, including high-power licensed exclusive use” and license sales should go toward clearing “the national debt.”
The FCC’s Consumer Advisory Committee will meet virtually June 26, starting at 11 a.m. EDT, the FCC said Thursday. CAC last met in April (see [Ref:2404040040).
The FCC on Thursday approved 3-2 a three-year, $200 million cybersecurity pilot program for schools and libraries. Commissioners Brendan Carr and Nathan Simington dissented, as some had predicted (see 2406040039). The two cited concerns with the FCC using E-rate program funds for the effort. Commissioners Geoffrey Starks and Anna Gomez indicated changes were inserted into the pilot rules at their request.
FCC commissioners unanimously approved an NPRM Thursday proposing specific reporting requirements on the nation's largest broadband providers regarding their border gateway protocol (BGP) security practices. "What was meant to be a short-term solution developed on the sidelines of an internet engineering conference is still with us today," Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel said during the commissioners' open meeting. "While BGP has allowed network operators to grow and evolve the modern internet, it was not designed with explicit security features to ensure trust in exchanged information," Rosenworcel said. Also adopted was an NPRM proposing an update of the commission's letter of credit (LOC) rules for its USF high-cost programs serving rural communities and an NPRM changing low-power TV station rules.
An FCC proposal that requires disclosing AI-generated content in political ads seems aimed at having rules ready for the 2024 presidential election, statements Thursday from FCC Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel and agency spokespeople indicate. However, broadcast insiders told us there probably isn’t enough time for that to happen without causing severe disruption. The FCC is proposing an update of the political file rules “to meet the moment we are in,” Rosenworcel said during a news conference. Her statement was in response to a question about whether the rules would be in effect on Election Day. Rosenworcel didn't explicitly say the item was intended for the 2024 election, though. “She has been clear that the time to act on public disclosure of AI use is now,” an agency spokesperson said in an email after being asked to clarify the planned timing of the proposal.