Windstream supported dismissing a New Mexico probe into the carrier’s service quality (see 1802020052). In a Tuesday response in docket 17-00081-UT, Windstream agreed with a Friday recommendation by Public Regulation Commission staff to dismiss. Windstream asked the PRC to put several findings in the dismissal order. The PRC should say only the FCC may regulate Windstream broadband because it’s an interstate service, the PRC lacks jurisdiction over franchise fees, Windstream complied with state USF reporting requirements, and Windstream resolved service quality concerns flagged by the PRC, the company said. The PRC should say the telecom provider lost its midsized carrier status Sept. 30, 2016, when its access line count dipped below 50,000, meaning midsize carrier rules including on those service quality would no longer apply, Windstream said.
The Nebraska Public Service Commission expects CTIA to drop its appeal of a PSC order shifting state USF to connections-based contributions, a PSC spokesman said after commissioners voted 5-0 Tuesday for an order revising definitions for the contested order in docket NUSF-100. Adopting definitions from a Friday stipulation by CTIA, Cox and other Nebraska carriers, the PSC redefined connections-based contribution mechanism as “a fixed or flat rate surcharge assessed on a per-connection basis,” connection as “any form of technology used to provide an end-user with access to an assessable service” and assessable service as “any service subject to a contribution obligation” to Nebraska USF. The industry stipulation said the appeal by CTIA and other parties at the Nebraska Court of Appeals would end after the PSC adopted the definitions. The commission, meanwhile, is weighing USF rate design in docket NUSF-111. CTIA earlier pulled a similar lawsuit against the Utah PSC after reaching agreement with that agency (See 1807030046). CTIA didn't comment.
CenturyLink “strongly supports” a connections-based New Mexico USF surcharge, the ILEC commented Friday in docket 17-00202-UT at the Public Regulation Commission. “The current revenue-based approach is not sustainable or competitively neutral.” Connections would tie New Mexico USF “to a growing base rather than a declining revenue base,” and would be “relatively easy to implement, administer and enforce,” it said. It wouldn’t burden federal USF because it’s not dependent on providers’ classification of revenue as intrastate or interstate, CenturyLink said. But CTIA said New Mexico should maintain revenue-based USF contribution. Connections-based contribution is “regressive, imposing a larger burden on the consumers least able to pay it,” and could “create an illegal overlap with or a burden on the federal fund,” CTIA said. The PRC wouldn’t be able to assess prepaid customers who lack a direct and ongoing billing relationship with their providers, it said. PRC staff urged caution. “Any changes to the collection methodology for the revenue side of the Fund must not be speculative nor based on conjecture,” wrote PRC staff attorney Joan Ellis. “The Commission must have ‘substantial evidence’ to support a decision to adopt that new methodology.”
The FCC approved 175 rate-of-return telcos to get $36 million more in annual USF support, cumulatively, under an Alternative Connect America Cost Model, in exchange for extending broadband to additional locations, said a Wireline Bureau public notice in docket 10-90 in Monday's Daily Digest. The RLECs accepted 210 of 217 state-level revised offers of model-based support made by the bureau implementing a March order (see 1805080028 and 1803230025). An accompanying report showed the revised amounts and deployment duties of carriers.
The FCC should eliminate USF silos to more efficiently target support, ex-Commissioner Mignon Clyburn said Monday at a livestreamed Next Century Cities broadband summit in Pittsburgh. Policymakers must balance broadband support for rural and urban areas, she and other current and former government officials said. Broadband issues shouldn’t divide political parties, they said, but Brookings Institution Senior Fellow Blair Levin noted the subject frequently ignites fights between Democrats and Republicans.
Stable FCC and other government subsidies are critical to sustaining Alaska’s General Communication Inc.'s investment in the state, General Counsel Tina Pidgeon said on C-SPAN’s The Communicators in a segment that was to have been televised Saturday. USF funding, including high-cost, E-rate and rural healthcare programs, must be predictable for GCI to spend money upgrading and extending services, she said: Alaska takes rural issues to “a different level,” with rugged terrain and low-population communities spread apart by thousands of miles. GCI uses microwave transport and LTE over satellite to serve the more difficult areas with broadband and wireless services, she said. Alaska regulators are weighing revamp of state USF (see 1805300054).
It's "extremely troubling" the FCC proposed a 15-year telco separations freeze "without any consideration of the recommendation" from federal-state joint board members, emailed Colorado Public Utilities Commissioner Wendy Moser, the state member who sponsored a NARUC-passed resolution backing a two-year freeze (see 1807180018). “Given that the majority of the Joint Board rests with the state members, and all that is needed for a recommended decision is a majority, the FCC should take the Joint Board recommended decision as submitted by the states. The FCC can then decide whether to adopt it or explain why not. ... Given the simplicity of the process, one has to wonder what the FCC is trying to accomplish in acting contrary to Congress' intent of having a Joint Board in the first place.”
The FCC cleared several RLEC deals with conditions to address cost-shifting concerns due to their combination of both model-based and cost-based high-cost USF support. The Wireline Bureau granted applications to transfer control of: Westphalia phone and broadband companies to Chapin Communications in docket 17-101; of Scott-Rice Telephone from Allstream Business US to New Ulm Telecom in docket 18-68; of Peoples Mutual phone companies to RiverStreet Management Services in docket 17-365; of Ellerbe Telephone to RiverStreet in docket 18-94; of Tri-County Telephone Membership to Wilkes Telephone Membership in docket 18-95; and of certain assets of Coon Creek phone and telecom companies to Shellsburg Cablevision in 18-177. To mitigate the potential for harmful cost shifting in mixing different types of USF support, the bureau attached conditions established in a Hargray/ComSouth order (see 1805110048), said a public notice in Thursday's Daily Digest: "The combined operating expense ... for each post-consummation company’s rate-of-return affiliates shall be capped at the averaged combined operating expense of the three calendar years preceding the transaction closing date for which operating expense data are available."
The FCC launched its urban rate survey to set "reasonable comparability" benchmarks for fixed voice and broadband services in 2019 in the USF Connect America Fund. Completed surveys are due Aug. 24, after being sent out Wednesday to a sample of fixed service providers identified through December 2017 Form 477 data, said a Wireline Bureau public notice in docket 10-90 in Wednesday's Daily Digest.
The FCC announced a $2.33 billion Lifeline budget for 2019 and updated minimum standards for fixed and mobile broadband services supported by the USF low-income subsidy program, said a Wireline Bureau public notice Wednesday in docket 11-42. Indexing for inflation, the budget for next calendar year was increased from 2018's $2.28 billion. The minimum fixed broadband standards, based on Form 477 and urban rate survey data, take effect Dec. 1. The minimum speed will be 18/2 Mbps, with an exception for providers that don't offer that capability in any generally available residential package to a subscriber's residence (they could offer the highest speed they can, and at least 4/1 Mbps). The minimum fixed broadband data usage will be 1,000 GB per month. Under a 2016 order schedule, the mobile broadband data usage standard was increased to 2 GB per month, while the minimum mobile speed remains at 3G level. Under the 2016 order, the minimum mobile voice service standard will increase to 1,000 minutes per month.