Research Is Missing on 3D TV Health Risks, ATSC Report Says
Much more research on 3D TV health issues is needed before widespread terrestrial 3D broadcasting can begin, said the interim report on visual sciences that recently was released by an Advanced Television Systems Committee planning team (CED March 24 p1). It exposes huge gaps in knowledge and understanding, along with the Catch-22 issue of what meaningful research can be safely done on viewers of all ages when little is known about possible side effects.
Sign up for a free preview to unlock the rest of this article
Communications Daily is required reading for senior executives at top telecom corporations, law firms, lobbying organizations, associations and government agencies (including the FCC). Join them today!
Without useful evidence of safety, broadcasters face the quandary over playing it safe with mild 3D effects that are less likely to cause health problems, and airing dramatic 3D effects that sell the idea of format but are more likely to give viewers headaches or nausea, the report said. One likely option, taking a page from Nintendo’s 3DS, will be for TV makers “to provide 3D displays that will allow end users to adjust the depth information contained in a scene to match individual’s preference,” the report said. ATSC’s planning team thinks 3D TV “provides a significant enhancement” over regular HD, but warns that the “simulation is not perfect and, depending on how the 3D content is created, processed and displayed, the end users’ experience can either be enhanced or made uncomfortable and potentially painful,” the report said.
The report cited “much-conversed negative side effects of watching stereoscopic images, such as watery eyes, visual strain, headaches, and sometimes blurred or double vision. In particular, visual safety issues of long-term effects of watching stereoscopic images are important concerns. Viewers tend to prefer 3D content over 2D, the report said. That’s “only when the 3D version is comfortable to view and any visible artifacts that arise from anywhere along the delivery chain are not annoying in the 3D presentation,” it said.
Creating and displaying 3D TV content “offers many benefits to increasing the viewer experience and enhancing revenue,” the report said. But “it will require more bandwidth, which is scarce and if done improperly, can result in a negative and potentially painful experience for their viewers,” the report said. “Clearly technology can solve many of the issues, but given the subjective nature of the impact of many of the factors, more information is needed to better understand and implement the services."
Particular care must be taken with 3D programming for children, because “the critical period for the development of stereopsis in humans is well-defined,” the report said. “Onset occurs at approximately 3 months of age, followed by a rapid period of maturation until 8 to 18 months of age, and a more gradual improvement until at least 3 years of age.” Little is known for sure about how many in the general population are “stereo-deficient,” the report said. Estimates of how many people can’t properly view 3D range all over the map, it said.